Press "Enter" to skip to content

The Challenge of Animation: Tax Credits?! Again?! Saskatchewan axes film tax credit.

We never seem to get this right, do we?  Nova Scotia bungled their tax credit legislation a few years ago and saw hundreds of animators leave the province in a matter of months when all the contracts went elsewhere.  New Brunswick dumped their legislation entirely, but then shifted to a digital media credit (but not after scaring the pants off their own film community and driving away business).  Now it’s Saskatchewan’s turn to choose to be non-competitive.

Here’s the article from the Hollywood Reporter, posted word-for-word:

Indie producers in the Canadian province immediately criticized the provincial government for leaving their local production sector without a future.

TORONTO – There’s no certainty about film tax credits these days, even in Canada.

The provincial government of Saskatchewan, releasing its latest fiscal budget on Wednesday, announced it will eventually scrap its long-standing film employment tax credit for cost savings.

From April 1, the provincial ministry of tourism, parks, culture and sport will no longer accept applications for a refundable 45 percent film tax credit, based on labor costs.

The credit will eventually be phased out at the end of 2014, after all remaining tax rebate obligations are paid out.

The provincial ministry in a release said the film tax credit had cost the government around $100 million since first launched in 1998, and scrapping it will eventually save around $8 million annually.

Saskatchewan indie producers criticized the provincial government Wednesday for leaving the local industry without a future.

“Quite frankly, without the tax incentive program, the province will be seen as an irrelevant location and production will not take place,” Vanessa Bonk, executive director of the Saskatchewan Motion Picture Industry Association, said.

Film and TV series that were supported by the film tax credit in Saskatchewan over the years includedTerry Gilliam’s Tideland and Canadian sitcoms like Corner Gas and Little Mosque on the Prairies, which has just wrapped its last season.

Recent film shoots include writer/director Armen Evrensel’s sci-fi comedy Space Milkshake, which shot in fall 2011 and starred Billy Boyd and Kristin Kreuk.

Other frugal Canadian provinces have revamped their tax credits for cost savings.

New Brunswick in March 2011 stunned local film and TV producers by phasing out a 40 percent tax credit to cut the provincial debt.

But, faced with a talent exodus to rival province, the Atlantic province later reintroduced a film incentive that rebates up to 30 percent of eligible expenditures.

The new program in New Brunswick gives 50 percent of the government money to indie producers up front for pre-production or production, with the other half coming when a project has finished production.

By contrast, the provinces of British Columbia, Ontario and Quebec, where most foreign production takes place in Canada, have in recent sold their film and digital tax credits for foreign producers on their certainty and bankability.

One might comment that Saskatchewan doesn’t have a huge industry to begin with, but this kind of all-encompassing hatchet job basically guarantees that no film work will get done there.  The Atlantic provinces are still reeling, and the last line really nails it on the head.  Why do all the contracts go to Ontario, BC or Quebec?  The certainty and bankability of the tax credits in those provinces look real good to those bankrolling productions.  Business is about minimizing risk.  Fluctuating tax credit policy is thin ice, pure and simple.

Tim Tyler, if you’re reading this, best of luck.  Very sorry to hear this news.


  1. Murray Bain Murray Bain March 22, 2012

    was it this program?:
    out of that 8 million a year given to productions, it was based on a 45% of labor, so that means 18 million in jobs lost!(probably 35 – 50 people directly) plus the producers spend money in the remote province because of the tax credit- overhead and expenses, rent, groceries,income, property, and sales tax from those employed, travel and craft services etc.
    probably 30-ish million gets spent in the province because of that 8 million in tax credits.
    I don’t understand how provincial finance departments see this as “savings.”

  2. gfowler gfowler March 22, 2012

    TV Shows wrapping up, none of note in the works and most of the workers own small shops or are seasonal workers at best. This is what your government is thinking.

    Quite simple you need a big building with a big logo on the side of it full of full-time workers in order for any government to support subsidizing the content business. This is what they need to justify it to their teams and to the public. I can see their point, but they forget that content creation in the province creates a culture. Which in most cases is more important than the money it takes to subsidize it. Culture created in the province gives the province an identity. Which EVERY province needs in order to be top of mind for opportunities.

    NB went through this when Fatkat fell in 2008-2009. However we have a strong enough film community that rallied against it. NB changed it course, eliminating the blanket tax credit. Instead we have a grant/incentive program that goes towards content creation of any sort. It’s quite lucrative too, which enables us to bring in better projects and support our creative community (in Loogaroo’s case).

    I feel for you Tim, but dont’ you dare give up. It can be reversed, the creators in NS did it and we did here just this year in NB. You can do it too.

    Rally the troops,


  3. Mark Mayerson Mark Mayerson March 22, 2012

    In Ontario, we’re waiting for the next provincial budget, due very soon. We’ll see if the tax credits survive or are altered.

  4. Lashbera Lashbera March 28, 2012

    I wish the government would give me a tax credit also but no small business will ever be on that list so as I struggle to make a living I can only say that what the government is doing is only fair. If every industry that asks for cash gets it we would have a ndp gov. And huge mounting debt.

Leave a Reply